Hey, YoungProdigy here. I'm looking for critique on my orchestral piece. You can listen to it here:
https://soundcloud.c...digy-epic-theme
I'm mainly looking for critique on my mixing and how I can improve it.
Not many can claim 25 years on the Internet! Join us in celebrating this milestone. Learn more about our history, and thank you for being a part of our community!
Hey, YoungProdigy here. I'm looking for critique on my orchestral piece. You can listen to it here:
https://soundcloud.c...digy-epic-theme
I'm mainly looking for critique on my mixing and how I can improve it.
The idea is nice (sounds like it would be useful in a game), but you should use more quality sounds. The drums are pretty basic. It sounds more like a MIDI file. You have skills though. What software did you make it on so I can be fair in my critique.
The idea is nice (sounds like it would be useful in a game), but you should use more quality sounds. The drums are pretty basic. It sounds more like a MIDI file. You have skills though. What software did you make it on so I can be fair in my critique.
Thanks. I think in my case it's more the mixing that's the problem other than the sounds. I do agree that the samples could be better though. I used FL Studio to sequence it and samples from Sampletank 3.
If you used FL studio, then you are good. I haven't used that in years. I used to use Reason 4.0 when I had it, but I had a bunch of sample instruments. The new reason has VST support I believe (that was a plus for FL studio).
I remember I had to compose a whole orchestral piece using this one program that only let you lay down the notes on a staff. So, note by dote I had to create the song. It was a cool experience.
Now that I think about it, it would be nice if the engine I use had MIDI support, and let us switch out the tracks with our own sounds, or even re-arnage the MIDI file.
If you have an Apple device you can get some nice sound out of Garageband.
Anyhow. Good job. Keep doing what you do.
You get a good bang for you buck with Sampletank. Lot of cool stuff in there and it's really cheap.
Hey there, YoungProdigy,
Right now, I feel like the mixing on this piece is a little rough. The EQ is decently balanced, and you've got a good mix of instruments covering a wide timbre spectrum. For me right now though, I feel like the reverb is too dry, and although there's a little panning going on, I really don't get a sense of the instruments being in separate locations. Can I ask what kind of reverb you're using here?
I use FL too and honestly I'm not really good at mixing and I had a friend to do the "final mixing" for me, but I think your track is good overall but I agree with comment above for dry reverb
at 0:13 you could add an instrument for transition :) about 2 beats before new bar.. well something to "hint" for new changes..